Check to see if you have 1 kicker #1 for kickoffs and the other kicker #1 for field goal kicker. If this is true, I believe it is because in the pre-season starters are taken out after 1,2,... quarters. Technically, if they are both starters, neither will play when starters are taken out, hence the position players will do the kicking.
EDIT - Okay, I only saw page 1 before posting. And I see JDB has answered this! Carry on...
Last edited at 11/29/2017 4:28 pm